Barnardo’s controversy
By Sophie Moore, 10 December 2008
An advertisement for children’s charity Barnardo’s that aims to raise awareness of domestic child abuse seems to have hit a raw nerve. The ad – which depicts a young girl caught in a cycle of violence, underachievement at school and drugs – has led to some 400-plus viewers complaining to the Advertising Standards Authority about the nature of its ostensibly distressing and offensive content.
You only need to watch the ad once to gain an understanding as to why the response was so strong. Yes, the ad is distressing – but what it does manage to do with some success, I would argue – is communicate the underlying message with clarity, which is vital to any campaign with the primary goal of awareness-raising. The ad only airs after 9pm – not a slot ideally placed to be accessible to young children, one of the demographics most likely to be ill-equipped to deal with its content. An issue like child abuse is unpleasant to confront, so why should its treatment in the media be lighthearted? Many of us claim to be virtually desensitised to what we see on our screens. If so, perhaps this ad is an example of when so-called ‘shock tactics’ are necessary if not just.

