During a recent marketing training day delivered by IE to attendees from not-for-profit organisations, MD Ollie Leggett made a couple of seemingly commonsensical points about the need for brands to behave with integrity. You probably don’t even need to be involved in the marketing/communications-related industries to understand that the ‘Three Cs’ – or credibility, clarity and consistency – are the life blood of the healthy brand. However it seems that sometimes even the pros let one of marketing’s golden rules slip by.
In a news item appearing in Marketing, CEO of The Partners Jim Prior provides an excellent and highly topical case study of the consequences of disjointed branding by analysing the decline of one of the long familiar faces on the high street, Woolworths. The article is worthy reading material on several levels. Even if all it does for the reader is reaffirm the need for brands to behave in a ‘joined up’ fashion, then it does this in a succinct and persuasive manner. Prior writes: ‘[Woolworths] is a proposition of authenticity, of democracy, of variety, of carefree, guilt-free indulgence… a proposition that everybody wanted but that just never got delivered against. It went unnoticed by the management of the company who, instead, pointlessly fragmented the brand into the Big W warehouse stores and a wholesale distribution business. Did anyone there have any idea what Woolworths really was?’
Prior doesn’t allow Woolworths the luxury of economic downturn as an excuse for the decline which does, granted, seem ruthless, but again he has a point. The weak spot much of the UK had for Woolies just wasn’t enough to compensate for the meagre experience of visiting a store. Do many of us actually know anyone who shops there regularly? Probably not, and there’s a reason for that. To what extent can a couple of generations’ nostalgia for pick n mix sustain a business that actually has little to offer to most shoppers?
I wouldn’t like to claim that IE’s branding experts could have saved the long-ailing Woolworths had they been brought in to do so. However I do think that in the current climate, where already-stretched businesses are competing for the few pennies their customers can afford to part with, an identity crisis – where tone of voice, visual signature and customer experience simply don’t correspond – represents a lot more than just a hindrance on the path to marketing bliss.